Thursday, September 17, 2009
Spanking detrimental to children, study says
(CNN) -- Think a little spanking won't do much harm to kids? New research says the effects can be long-lasting.
Experts say "popping" kids can do more harm than good. A new study of more than 2,500 toddlers from low-income families found that spanking may have detrimental effects on behavior and mental development.
"We're talking about infants and toddlers, and I think that just, cognitively, they just don't understand enough about right or wrong or punishment to benefit from being spanked," said Lisa Berlin, the study's lead author and research scientist at the Center for Child and Family Policy at Duke University.
Berlin and colleagues found that children who were spanked as 1-year-olds tended to behave more aggressively at age 2, and did not perform as well as other children on a test measuring thinking skills at age 3. The study is published in the journal Child Development.
Although these effects were somewhat small, the study is just the latest of many supporting psychologists' advice against spanking. Still, some experts say spanking has a time and place.
The new study focused on children from low-income families because prior research suggested that spanking is more common among them, Berlin said. This may be because of the added stresses of parenting in a low-income situation, or because of a "cultural contagion" of behaviors among people. For example, in some families this study examined, a grandmother would spank a child, or neighbors would encourage physical discipline, she said.
Her study found that about one-third of the 1-year-olds, and about half of the 2- and 3-year-olds, had been spanked in the previous week, according to mothers' self-reporting to the researchers. At all three ages, African-American children were spanked significantly more frequently than those from white and Mexican-American families, and verbally punished more than the other children at ages 2 and 3, the study said.
Previous research had also found that parents who spank are more likely to be younger, less educated, single, and/or depressed and stressed, Berlin's study said. Spanking is most commonly used among parents who were spanked themselves, who live in the South, and/or who identify themselves as conservative Christians. These parents also tend to believe in the effectiveness of spanking or believe the child is at fault in a given situation, the study said.
The new research refutes the idea that more aggressive children are more likely to be spanked, Berlin said. On the other hand, the study did find that children who were fussier at age 1 were more likely to be spanked and verbally punished, she said.
Verbal punishment did not appear to have the same detrimental effects as spanking in this study, Berlin said.
Some remain unconvinced that parents should never spank their children. Robert Larzelere, associate professor of human development and family science at Oklahoma State University, conducted a meta-analysis of 26 studies on the subject, and found that, overall, spanking seemed more effective than 10 of 13 alternative disciplinary methods for getting a child to behave or do as asked.
Much of the research on the subject does not clearly demonstrate a causal link, Larzelere said. For example, in comparing studies, children who are spanked and children who are taken to psychologists both are more likely to have aggressive behavior later, he said.
The best use of spanking, Larzelere said, is in children between the ages of 2 and 6 when milder discipline tactics, such as time out, fail.
"That's why psychologists trained parents to use spanking that way for 25 years [from the] late '60s to mid-'90s," he said. Now, the trend of advice is away from spanking, but there's not much hard evidence to support it, he said.
Berlin's study focused on particularly early ages, Larzelere noted; much of the spanking literature focuses on ages 2 and older. Twelve months is probably too early to spank children, but there's no established point between ages 1 and 2 at which it is appropriate, he said.
Others say parents should not resort to spanking at any age. Susan Newman, social psychologist and author of "Little Things Long Remembered: Making Your Children Feel Special Every Day," said parents should discourage bad behaviors by taking away privileges such as dessert, or setting an earlier bedtime. They should also reinforce good behaviors verbally, saying how nice it is when their children share, for example.
The study corroborates what clinical psychologist Laura Markham, who was not involved in the study, has observed about the negative effects of spanking. Many mothers describe their children as fussy, resistant and demanding at age 1, which is a critical junction in the parent-child relationship, she said in an e-mail.
"If the mother sees this fussiness as willful misbehavior and begins verbally punishing or spanking, rather than empathizing with the child, the child's behavior deteriorates into more tantrums and other frustrating behavior," said Markham, who also offers advice at AhaParenting.com.
Newman also noted that children are too young to understand when parenting behavior is wrong, even at the level of abuse. Physical violence gets passed down in families because the only parenting skills people know are the behaviors that they saw at home, she said.
Spanking, moreover, reinforces negative memories in the child's mind, Newman said. Parents should aim instead to build "prominent, happy memories" of childhood for their kids, she said.
Regardless of income level, all parents can benefit from training classes, Newman said.
For future research, Berlin is looking at programs that work with low-income or high-risk families and try to promote supportive parenting behaviors.
In the spanking study, some mothers said they were receiving parenting services in which they were counseled not to spank their children.
"This is definitively the direction in which services are going and in which, in general, American culture is going," Berlin said.
source : CNN
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
Blog Archive
-
▼
2009
(2180)
-
▼
September
(469)
- Ludovico Einaudi
- Body Painting - Bra - Series #2
- Charlotte Carey Ad Campaign for Rock & Republic, F...
- my style influence part. I
- Beauty and Fashion Reads From The Style News Network
- How To Get Ashley Greene’s Hairstyle
- Eugenia Mandzhieva Editorial for UK Elle, Septembe...
- Identität
- Philip Huang Ad Campaign for Tommy Hilfiger, Fall ...
- Body painting - Flower - Series #5
- Du Juan Editorial for Vogue China, October 2009
- My MUA & Specktra Swap Haul!!
- A huge update!
- How To Get Katy Perry’s Makeup Look
- "Melrose" Best and Worst Hairstyles
- MACABRE " rumah dara "
- Liu Wen Ad Campaign for DKNY, Fall 2009/Winter 2010
- Ways To Store Makeup - Containers
- Harajuku Girls Launch Snow Bunnies
- Fall 2009 Guerlain Slavic Beauty/Russian Beauty Co...
- Du Juan Editorial for Vogue China, October 2009
- Elize
- Gwen Lu Editorial for (Malaysia) New Tide, Septemb...
- addicted to lipstick weekly reads from style news ...
- Urban Decay Holiday Collection for 2009
- Liu Wen Editorial for Vogue China, October 2009
- Rien ne va plus
- Shu Pei Editorial for Elle China, September 2009
- The Importance of Consequential Strangers
- Giant panda
- ZZ: Does She or Doesn’t She?
- Chris Packham says giant pandas should die out
- News Today
- Dream Becomes Lowest Rated Drama In 2009
- Soo Ae Graces Vogue
- Super Junior-M for Numero
- Michael Caine on 'Batman 3': No Johnny Depp
- 'Pandorum' Plot Unfolded in New Featurette
- 'X-Men 4' Could Be on the Way
- Details on 'Toy Story 3' Trailer
- Miley Cyrus Lashes Out at Paparazzi
- Cheryl Cole Vows to Never Pose Nude
- Alexandra Burke's 'Bad Boys' Video Feat. Flo Rida ...
- Mika Announces a One-Off Live Concert in Sydney
- It's Official, Keisha Buchanan Quits Sugababes
- Lady GaGa Leads 2009 MTV Europe Music Awards Noms
- Kris Allen Debuts Single 'Live Like We're Dying'
- Schikeria
- Behind the Scenes of Amerie's 'Heard 'Em All' Musi...
- First Teaser of 'Camp Rock 2'
- Previews of 'One Tree Hill' 7.03 and 'Gossip Girl'...
- 'Heroes' 4.03 Preview: Claire Covering Up Her Tracks
- Tina Fey Wants Justin Timberlake on '30 Rock'
- 'House M.D.' 6.03 Preview: House to Quit
- First Clip From 'Smallville' Season 9 Premiere
- Full 'The Twilight Saga's New Moon' Soundtrack Lis...
- Brad Pitt in Talks for 'Sherlock Holmes 2'
- Exclusive Interview: Clifton Collins Jr. on Paul S...
- Khloe Kardashian and Lamar Odom to Wed This Weekend
- Jason Segel and Chloe Sevigny Reportedly Dating
- Rep Confirms David Hasselhoff's Weekend Hospitaliz...
- Fall 2009 Barbie Loves Stila Swatches and Review
- Bobbi Brown Pink Ribbon Collection
- The 20 Fastest Growing Facebook Apps: Mostly Socia...
- Las Vegas: 10 Things to Do in 24 Hours
- NTV plans "Arashi Challenge Week"
- Body identified as "Crayon Shin-chan" creator
- Du Juan Ad Campaign for Anna Sui for Target, Fall...
- Researchers: Daily Dose of Aspirin May Cut Colon C...
- WHO: H1N1 No Deadlier, But Early Signs It's Develo...
- How Not to Get Sick, Childhood 0-12
- The Madrid Fashion Week, Spring/Summer 2010 collec...
- Nintendo Wii Review: Dawn of Discovery
- Anime DVD Review - Kaze no Stigma Volume 2: Fire
- Anime DVD Review: ‘Samurai Champloo’ The Complete ...
- Nintendo Wii Review: Wii Sports Resort
- Mad Men Season 3 Episode 6: Guy Walks into an Adve...
- Beyonce Knowles Confirms Upcoming Malaysia Gig Des...
- New Poster of 'Grey's Anatomy' Season 6
- New Footage From 'Avatar' Found in Japanese Panaso...
- Singer Lucinda Williams Weds Manager Tom Overby on...
- The 2009 Emmy Awards
- Shakira's 'She Wolf' Album Release Pushed Back
- Early Winners of 61st Annual Primetime Emmy Awards
- '30 Rock' and 'Mad Men' Snag Best Series at 61st E...
- Neil Patrick Harris' Opening Number and Dance Trib...
- Oprah Winfrey-Produced 'Precious' Grabs Top Toront...
- 'Cloudy with a Chance' Rolls to Top North American...
- 2009 Emmy Awards' Red Carpet Arrival
- Zooey Deschanel and Fiance Ben Gibbard Wed
- Pregnant Heidi Klum and Kourtney Kardashian Speak ...
- Son Tae Young likes being Mrs. Kwon
- Kim Hee Sun releases more baby photos
- Pictures of f(x) Amber birthday party
- Sony Slams YG Entertainment for Plagiarism Issues!
- What Made 2NE1’s Minzy Cry?
- MAC Style Black Mineralize Shadows! yum.
- My Back to MAC Lipstick - High Tea!
- London Fashion Week: PPQ
- The PPQ fashion show during London Fashion Week
-
▼
September
(469)
0 comments:
Post a Comment