By Fiona Macrae
Women and children are seen rowing away from the sinking ship in a scene taken from 1997 film Titanic
When the Titanic sunk, the safety of women and children came first. But when the Lusitania went down three years later, it was a case of survival of the fittest.
A pain-staking analysis of passenger data from the two vessels revealed that captain's orders to allow women and children off first were adhered to when the Titanic hit an iceberg on her maiden voyage on April 14, 1912.
But when the Lusitania was torpedoed by a German submarine off the coast of Ireland three years later, it was a case of every man for himself.
More precisely, men and women aged between 16 and 35 were most likely to push their way to safety, the journal Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences reports.
The difference in behaviour, the researchers believe, lies not in who was on the ships, but how quickly they went down.
The Titanic took almost three hours to sink, giving at least some of the passengers time to regain their cool and remember their manners.
Women were up to 54 per cent more likely to have lived than men, and under-15s were 32 per cent more likely to survive than the over-50s.
But the Lusitania, which was sailing from New York, took less than 20 minutes, and panic was the order of the day, with the young and fit pushing their way onto the lifeboats - and staying on them.
The RMS Lusitania, the British ship torpedoed by a German submarine during World War I
Researcher Professor Bruno Frey, of Switzerland's Zurich University, said: 'Because the Lusitania sank in under 18 minutes, we would expect a stronger competition for survival of the fittest on that ship than on the Titanic.
'People in their prime, age 16 to 35 years, are expected to have higher survival probabilities.
'However, a higher survival rate may be a result not only of the struggle for a place on a lifeboat but also of an inefficient launching of the lifeboats on the Lusitania.
'Individuals who were strong and agile enough to stay in the boats or to get back into the boats after being pitched into the water had a higher survival rate.
'The social norm of "women and children first" was deferred to only on the Titanic.'
Knowledge of the fate of the Titanic may have heightened the panic on the Lusitania.
Professor Frey said: 'The likelihood that the passengers of the Lusitania knew about the tragic events of the sinking of the Titanic should not be excluded.
'For example, while many of the passengers on the Titanic may have (wrongly) believed they would ultimately be rescued, those on the Lusitania may have learned from the experience of the Titanic.
'This may have led passengers to increase self-preserving behaviour.'
A previous analysis by the same team revealed that Britons aboard the Titanic were more likely to exhibit good manners by queuing for lifeboats and allowing the vulnerable to board first than other nationalities.
It is thought the phenomenon explains why British passengers were the most likely to perish.
Professor Frey said: 'The Americans at the time were not very cultured, while the English were still gentlemen.'
Just 706 of the Titanic's 2,223 passengers and crew survived and 1,198 lost their lives on the Lusitania.
source: dailymail
Tuesday, March 2, 2010
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
Blog Archive
-
▼
2010
(4606)
-
▼
March
(300)
- Jennifer Aniston shows off her sexy dance moves as...
- OOTD- Wearing Navy & Staying on Track
- Scientists achieve record high energy particle col...
- Shih-han Hsiao Editorial for NYTimes T Magazine, S...
- Daredevil makes return Base Jump from 4,000ft peak...
- Kick-Ass child star Chloe Moretz says mother allow...
- Did Victoria Beckham copy Osman? Posh dress is alm...
- MAC Liberty of London Peachstock & Ever Hip Lipsti...
- A Peek at my New Betsey Johnson Handbag!
- A Bad Day & Bronzing Products I Love
- Review: NARS Chelsea Girls Lip Lacquer + Photos & ...
- Bobbi Brown Long Wear Gel Liner in Black Ink + Pho...
- Dr. Brandt Pores No More Pore Refiner Review
- An Update..
- Elephants' legs propel them around just like a 4x4...
- Tao Okamoto Editorial for (French) Purple Magazine...
- Gerard Butler makes his escape... but it's not lon...
- Manchester United Train Ahead Of Bayern Munich
- Vanessa Perroncel Celebrates!
- Chinese Girl with Body Painting
- What's going on ear? Gemma Arterton unveils angel ...
- Two female suicide bombers kill at least 37 commut...
- The £30,000 chrome Mini Cooper which the buyers ca...
- Sun Fei Fei & Takashmi Watanabe Ad Campaign & Cata...
- Another white powder mystery for Lindsay Lohan as ...
- Russell Brand and Katy Perry put on a show of unit...
- Empire Film Awards: Aspiring actress Sarah Harding...
- Target Fitting Room Reviews: Random Selections
- Joe and Carly take new baby home
- Coleen at Liverpool
- Marseille Win French League Cup!
- Daniel Liu Ad Campaign for Liberty of London for T...
- Blue-haired Katy Perry sees the funny side after g...
- Michael Jackson investigators found stash of anaes...
- Over The Rainbow: The 10 Dorothy hopefuls unveiled...
- Bolton Wanderers 0-4 Manchester United
- Hair Coloring, Spring Cleaning, Couch Shopping & OOTD
- True Grit: America's daring ironworkers walk the g...
- Liu Wen Magazine Cover for WWD Beauty Biz, March 2010
- Over The Rainbow: The 20 Dorothys competing for th...
- Kelly Brook goes back to her pin-up roots as she b...
- Mac Liberty of London Swatches and Review
- James and Becks....What Can I Say More?
- David Beckham in Los Angeles
- Mancini vs Moyes
- Alex Gerrard's fetish for torn clothes
- Tao Okamoto Editorial for Vogue China, April 2010
- Angelic Miranda Kerr shares her diet tips as she s...
- OOTD: Still Wearing Tights
- David Beckham sports new tattoo in memory of his '...
- Angelina Jolie shows bella bambina Vivienne the si...
- Sun Fei Fei & Ming Xi in Style.com's Favorite New ...
- Victoria Beckham flashes the flesh at the Moscow l...
- Du Juan & Liu Wen Editorial for Vogue China, March...
- Nick and Caroline!
- Sans Wedding Ring, Ashley!
- Sandra Bullock's husband Jesse James 'had multiple...
- Why these cheating stars are a threat to your marr...
- You little swine: Emma Thompson is almost upstaged...
- Ladies Body painting
- Tim Gunn Coming to Houston & Bikini Season is Arou...
- Mac Too Fabulous Collection Swatches and Review
- Bobbi Brown Color Strips Collection
- Bar Refaeli shows her form in new lingerie ad... a...
- Does Taylor Swift have a Glee-ful new romance? Tee...
- Jasmine Yan Editorial for (Italian) A Magazine, Ma...
- 'Tiger Woods said his wife wasn't up for sex': Gol...
- So what have you been up to? After partying until ...
- Home Decor: Inspiration & What Styles Appeal to You?
- Ashley Cole Returns To Training
- Becks Jets Out to England
- David and Victoria Beckham go their separate ways ...
- Dancing With The Stars: Lewis Hamilton cheers on g...
- Kiki Kang Editorial for Teen Vogue, March 2010
- King Rooney!
- Alex Gerrard Caught With Sea Kelp diet pills
- Smiffy and Becks: The Story Continues
- Coleen is Shy after leaving hair saloon!
- Fab and Owen
- Staying with Tiger Woods seems to have its compens...
- Joe and Carly Cole wrap their newborn daughter up ...
- Skin So Soft Skincare Giveaway ( Must Have Twitte...
- How To Look Photogenic (Even If You're Not)
- Tao Okamoto Ad Campaign for Zac Posen, Spring/Summ...
- Did you forget your boots then? Katy Perry and Rus...
- 'Clap for me when I make golf comeback': Tiger Woo...
- Nadine Coyle joins Boyzone on stage for emotional ...
- Loving Now: Shorts with Pumps- "The Hills" Stars S...
- Daniel Liu & Jasmine Yan Editorial for Taiwan GQ, ...
- Tina Fey: How we fell in love with the queen of co...
- Sweet 15 - and Angelina Jolie knew exactly where s...
- "Le Roi" poses for GQ France.
- Victoria Beckham en route to LA
- Body Painting - Casino
- Part 2: So, you'd like to swap, aye? Here are some...
- Weekend Shopping: If You're Looking For Something,...
- Part 1: How to use Makeupalley (for beginners/new ...
- Cartoons of the Week, March 20 - March 26, 2010
- McLaren takes on Ferrari with 'affordable' £150,00...
- Shu Pei Editorial for 25 Magazine, March 2010
-
▼
March
(300)
0 comments:
Post a Comment