By Tara Kelly / London
Think of omega-3s as the oils that keep our brains and hearts from getting rusty. Hundreds of studies show that these essential fatty acids can help prevent cardiovascular disease and some scientists believe they are also beneficial for the brain and nervous system. But not all omega-3s are created equal. The ones with the biggest health benefits are found in fish like salmon and mackerel, which have the two long chain fatty acids docosahexaenoic (DHA) and eicosapentaenoic (EPA). Plant-derived omega-3s — the fatty acids found in flax seeds, olive oil and some leafy greens — don't contain these specific fatty acid chains. While they're also thought to be good for the heart, they don't have quite the same effect on the body as their fish-derived cousins.
"Both types of omega-3s are essential for our health because the body cannot make them on its own. [But] people who regularly consume fish have less chance of dying from heart disease. For plant-derived omega-3s, the suggestive evidence is unconvincing and more research needs to be done to make stronger claims," says Dariush Mozaffarian, an assistant professor of medicine and epidemiology at Harvard Medical School.
The difference between the two groups of omega-3s is now at the heart of a debate in the European Union. In 2007, the European Parliament passed a law allowing companies to tout the health benefits of omega-3s on their food products without having to differentiate between the plant-derived and fish-derived kinds. With the trial period due to expire in January 2010, the European Commission, the body that recommends which legislation will go before the Parliament, approved a proposal in October to make the statute permanent. The Parliament will decide on the issue in January.
Some experts are wary of the proposal, though. A group of 20 scientists from seven countries who specialize in fatty acids have warned it could allow food manufacturers to deceive consumers. They say that without clear labels, companies can use plant-derived omega-3s in their products and pass them off as the superior, fish-derived omega-3s. "They would be able to pour in cheap plant oils, but imply that they deliver the same health benefits as fish oils," says John Stein, a neurophysiology professor at Oxford University and one of the scientists urging the European Parliament to vote against the proposal and instead set up a scientific committee to advise on omega-3 food labeling.
Thanks to a love affair with French fries and cheeseburgers — not fish and vegetables — most Westerners' diets don't contain enough omega-3s. On top of that, we eat too many processed foods, which contain another fatty acid that hinders the body's ability to absorb omega-3s. This is one reason why food manufacturers have started putting more omega-3s into foods like margarine, mayonnaise and eggs in recent years.
Unilever, which sells margarine containing omega-3s, insists that its labels are accurate. The Anglo-Dutch company makes two different types of margarine, both of which it says are healthy. It produces margarine with omega-3 plant oils for vegetarians and margarine with omega-3 fish oils for people who eat fish, clearly stating on the labels which type of fatty acids are in each spread. "It's not a competition between these different omega-3s — all are essential for the diet, " says Anne Heughan, Unilever's director of external affairs for Europe. Moreover, she says, Unilever is within the guidelines set by the European Food and Safety Authority (EFSA) on nutritional labeling.
But the scientists say the EFSA guidelines only deal with a product's health claims about omega-3s, not its nutritional content. "We've got two types of claims in play at the same time. Health claims are about the effect on the eater, nutrition claims are about what is in the food. Pointing to the health claims alone is technically legal, but substantively misleading," says Jack Winkler, a professor at the Metropolitan University of London and another of the scientists who is against the E.U. law.
The debate hasn't reached the same level of specificity in the U.S. The Food and Drug Administration has given food companies the freedom to tout the health benefits of omega-3s without differentiating between the plant-derived and fish-derived kinds. Instead of worrying about food labels, scientists there are questioning whether the omega-3 benefits of fish consumption outweigh the risks of getting too much mercury. The FDA has taken a tough stance, advising women who are pregnant, nursing mothers and young children to avoid eating fish that is high in mercury, such as swordfish, king mackerel and tilefish, and to limit consumption of albacore tuna to six ounces per week.
source: Time.com
Saturday, October 31, 2009
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
Blog Archive
-
▼
2009
(2180)
-
▼
October
(152)
- News Today, November 01, 2009 (2)
- the annual Village Halloween Parade October 31, 20...
- This Is It makes $20m in one day
- MAC Freckletone Lipstick Dupe!! & Palladio Cosmeti...
- Seven Flaws Your Date Will Notice
- Mac Love Lace Collection
- 2009 Stila Holiday Collection
- In love with Cinque Terre
- Top 5: Date Ideas You Can Do Naked
- Defriending can bruise your 'digital ego'
- Selina Khan Test Shots
- Is Trick-or-Treating Dangerous?
- Cartoons of the Week October 31, 2009 - November 6...
- The Hunt for Tuna: A Tough Catch
- The Omega-3 Battle: Which Margarine Is Healthier?
- Visit Animals at Zoo
- Kris Allen's 'Live Like We're Dying' Video Due Nex...
- Preview of 'Smallville' 9.07: Jor-El in Person
- 'Ghost Whisperer' and 'Medium' November 6 Previews
- Fresh 'New Moon' Clip Offers Scene From Bella's Bi...
- Miley Cyrus Describes Her 'Sex and the City 2' Sho...
- Miley Cyrus Approves of Taylor Swift and Taylor La...
- Lady GaGa Plans to Dress Down on Halloween
- Amazing Halloween Wallpapers
- Sports Today, October 31, 2009
- His Holiness the Dalai Lama arrives in Japan
- News Today, October 31, 2009
- Hand painting - Butterfly
- Devon Aoki Ad Campaign for (Italian) Ra-Re, Fall 2...
- Taiwan Snacks
- Dating The Same Girl ?
- Internet domain names set to appear in non-Latin s...
- Halloween Candy Without the Heartburn
- 'Supernatural' 5.08 Preview: Sounds Like Trickster...
- 'CSI' 10.06 Preview: Death and the Maiden
- Charlize Theron and Tom Hardy Confirmed for 'Mad M...
- 'Men in Black 3' Moves Forward With Writer Etan Cohen
- Paris Hilton Hasn't Decided on What She's Going to...
- Lady GaGa to Be Handed the Stylemaker Award
- Joanna Krupa's Playboy Cover Revealed
- Video: Miley Cyrus Wants Twitter to Be Banned From...
- News Today, October 30, 2009
- Createurope 2009. In the Mix...
- Kreativ Blogger Award!
- Western Painting - Body Painting - A Contemporary ...
- 2009 Nars Holiday Collection
- This Week Style News Network Webtour
- Liu Wen Editorial for Vogue China, November 2009
- "Go Forth": Levi's neu kontextualisiert
- Body Painting - Chinese Cheong-sam
- Patti, Jeanine Chin, Dinara Chetyrova & Liu Dan Ed...
- OH!NENA
- Bless Sample Sale
- Tao Okamoto in Barney's Denim Co-op Catalog, Fall ...
- Review: YSL Touche Eclat - Radiant Touch
- Mac 2009 Holiday Swatches and Review
- Ditch Dark Circles and Puffiness for Good
- Body Painting - Picture Frame
- Ujjwala Raut Editorial for Vogue India, August 2009
- Body Painting Art - Nude Female and Male Body Pain...
- Review: MAKE UP FOREVER Waterproof Eyebrow Corrector
- Mac Blush Swatches
- Too Faced Decade of Glamour Vintage Palette Review...
- Body Painting - Hockey Player
- Charlotte Carey Magazine Cover and Editorial for (...
- Style New Weekly Tour
- 2009 Holiday Collection Estee Lauder Ultimate Red
- body art painting
- Lilly Pulitzer Teams Up With Mac for MAC in Lillyl...
- Hyoni Kang & Selina Khan Editorial for Teen Vogue,...
- Shu Pei Editorial for Vogue China, November 2009
- createurope #02 - morgen geht es los
- Body Painting Promo Girls - How to Make Money Gett...
- MAC Baroque Boudoir Collection
- 2009 Mac Halloween Face Charts and Images
- Top 10 Drugstore Acne-Fighting Products
- Kiki Kang Editorial for Vogue Taiwan, October 2009
- Jean Paul Gaultier "Classique" et "Le Mâle"
- Selina Khan Ad Campaign for Lacoste, Fall 2009/Win...
- Fashion Film....
- Smashbox Reign Eye Shadow Palette Swatches and Rev...
- Too Faced Shadow Insurance Review
- Sephora Friends and Family Sale
- Rila Fukushima Ad Campaign for (Japan) GAP, Holida...
- Stefanel AW 2009/2010 - alltäglich aufregend
- Sephora Platinum #55 Airbrush, yay or nay?
- Mac Dsquared2 Collection Review and Swatches
- Review: Giorgio Armani Luminous Silk Foundation!
- 2009 Guerlain Imperiale Holiday Collection
- My Sept/Oct. Favorites!
- NOTD: OPI Manicurist of Seville!
- Tao Okamoto Ad Campaign for Uniqlo Heattech, Fall ...
- Body Art Around the World
- Body Painting - 7 Tips For Cleaning Up Safely and ...
- Body Painting - A Look at the Top 6 Festivals in t...
- Body Painting - 3 Steps to Find the Best Supplies
- Ein Herz für Blogs
- Simon Tham Editorial for (Online) Contributing Edi...
- Adult Body Painting - What's the Fuss About?
- Free Face Painting Ideas
-
▼
October
(152)
0 comments:
Post a Comment